2008-2009
JOE ESPOSITO / BRIAN WILSON / KEVIN PANTALEANO

2007-2008
JOEY LANGEL / CODY FOBES / JASON ECKLOF / HARRY TURNER

2006-2007
JUSTIN MORELLO / JIMMY BOHN / TOM TUMINELLI

2005-2006
BILLY WOOWARD / FRANK MORMINO / SHAUN LYNCH

2004-2005
MARTY HOLLERAN / BILLY WOODWARD

2003-2004
CHRIS DESENA / MIKE SAVOYE

2002-2003
JAY UCCI / ZAC CUNLIFFE / CHRIS AQUINO

2001-2002
ROD CUNLIFFE / MATT INGRASSIA

2000-2001
E.J. LEJEUNE / JOE FORTUNATO

1999-2000
RAY LOPEZ / DAVE OLSON / PAT LAVIN

1998-1999
JOHN CORINGRATO / ED WHITTAKER / KEVIN ICKLES / JOSE SANCHEZ

1997-1998
JOHN VILLA / DAVID GOAD / DAVE PALMESE / MARC KASS

1996-1997
JOHN LAFFAN / RYAN MCELVEN / JOE ICKLES

1995-1996
JOHN GUSTAVSEN / DANNY BAUM / TIM ESPOSITO

1994-1995
WALTER BAYNE / JAY JANI / TODD GOING

1993-1994
STEVE FICARA / BRYAN DELL / JASON KARTALIS

1992-1993
KEITH SWISTOCK / ERIC MORAN

1991-1992
NO CAPTAINS

1990-1991
MANNY SCICOLONE / RAY SKWERES

1989-1990
JEROME RUNKO / MIKE CARR

1988-1989
BRIAN MORAN / RON REIFF / GLEN SANDULL

1987-1988
DEREK DEE / PAUL WHITTAKER

1986-1987
JOHN GAGLIANO / ROTATION

1985-1986
MIKE DUNN / PETER KRAJCSIK

1984-1985
FRANK METTA / JOE DIMICHELE

1983-1984
KEITH PREIS / SCOTT BILKER

1982-1983
PAT GAGLIANO / BARRY HALPRIN

1981-1982
PAT GAGLIANO / BARRY HALPRIN

1980-1981
JIM SCATIGNA / BARRY HALPRIN

1979-1980
KEVIN LAWLOR / JIM SCATIGNA / ROTATION

1978-1979
PAT TONER / JUAN DIAZ / JIM SCATIGNA

1977-1978
GEORGE MCCARTHY / TOM LAWLER / LOU SCATIGNA

1976-1977
NO CAPTAINS

1975-1976
ERIC BUMBERA / STEVE BUTTON

1974-1975
BERNARD CRUDUP / TOM DOYLE

1973-1974
TERRY BEINS / ROTATION

1972-1973
NILS DEACON / ART VANNOTE

1971-1972
ART BEINS / BILL GAERTNER

1970-1971
WILLIE KELLY / BILL GAERTNER

1969-1970
TONY BOMBACI / EUGENE TKACENK

1968-1969
TONY BOMBACI / CHARLES CALHOUN

1967-1968
ELADIO CUOTO / DAN THOMPSON

1966-1967
ALLEN ETTENBERG / STEVE NAVARRO

1965-1966
ORLANDO FONTANEZ / GEORGE CUOTO

1964-1965
CARLOS FONTANEZ / GEORGE SCHICK